Investors with large, concentrated stock positions often find themselves stuck between a rock and a hard place. On one hand, holding on to a single stock position exposes them to unnecessary risk. On the other, selling that stock can mean paying a hefty capital gains tax bill.
What most investors don’t realize is that there’s a third option—a relatively obscure yet entirely legitimate strategy that can help diversify away single-stock risk without triggering immediate taxes: exchange funds.
In this article, we’ll explore what exchange funds are, how they work, the advantages and disadvantages they present, and the types of investors who may benefit from using them.
If you’d rather watch the video version of this blog, make sure to check it out here:
Let’s begin.
What Are Exchange Funds?
Exchange funds (not to be confused with exchange-traded funds) are private investment vehicles that allow investors with concentrated stock positions to pool their holdings together. Each investor contributes a stock or group of stocks to the fund, and in return, they receive a pro-rata slice of a diversified portfolio made up of everyone’s contributions.
This mechanism enables two major benefits:
- Portfolio diversification without selling the original stock.
- Tax deferral, since the transaction is structured as an exchange—not a sale—under IRS rules.
Hence the name: exchange fund.
Why Not Just Sell and Diversify?
Let’s look at a simplified example.
Suppose you invested $10,000 into a stock that has now appreciated to $100,000. Let’s say that in this case if you sell it, you’d owe 20% in capital gains tax—cutting your investable amount down to $82,000.
Now let’s say you reinvest that $82,000 into a broad market fund that returns 7% annually for 10 years. You’d end up with around $161,000.
But if you had contributed your stock to an exchange fund instead—deferring the tax and still earning 7% annually—you’d end up with $197,000.
That $36,000 difference? It’s called tax drag—the hidden cost of paying taxes early, which includes not just the tax itself but the lost compound growth on that money over time.
Exchange funds help avoid this tax drag by allowing you to defer capital gains taxes until much later.
How Do Exchange Funds Work?
Exchange funds must meet specific requirements to maintain their tax-deferred status. Here are the key features:
1. Lock-Up Period
Investors generally must stay in the fund for at least seven years. If you exit earlier, you may be given your original stock back, and the IRS may treat the initial contribution as a taxable sale.
2. Limited Liquidity
Because of the lock-up, these funds are illiquid. If you need cash, some exchange funds allow you to borrow against your position, but that comes with interest charges and other risks.
3. Portfolio Composition
Exchange funds are generally composed of approximately 80% in publicly traded stocks that are contributed by the participating investors. The remaining 20% is usually allocated to illiquid “qualifying” assets, such as real estate. This structure is designed to help the fund meet certain tax requirements and resemble a limited partnership rather than a mutual fund.
These funds are structured to track broad indices or achieve market-like returns, but they’re not passive vehicles. The goal is risk reduction through diversification, not beating the market.
Who Are Exchange Funds For?
Exchange funds aren’t for everyone. Here’s what you need to qualify and participate:
| Pros | Cons |
| Diversification without a taxable event | Illiquidity: 7-year lock-up period |
| Avoidance of tax drag | High minimums: Contributions often range from $100K to $5M |
| Access to a broad portfolio while retaining your cost basis | Accredited investor requirement: Typically, a net worth of $1M+ or $200k personal or $300k household income |
| Limited stock acceptance: If your stock is already overrepresented, the fund may decline your contribution | |
| Fees: Usually higher than standard ETFs or mutual funds |
What Happens at Redemption?
After seven years, you’ll receive a diversified basket of stocks representing the fund’s holdings—again, without triggering a taxable event. Your original cost basis carries over, preserving the tax deferral benefit until you sell your portion of the distributed stocks.
Final Thoughts
For investors with large, concentrated stock positions, exchange funds offer a rare but powerful option: the ability to diversify without immediately triggering capital gains taxes. That said, they aren’t simple, and they aren’t for everyone.
Before considering one, it’s crucial to speak with a qualified tax advisor or financial planner who understands the nuances of these funds.
About the Author: Jose Ordonez
—
Important Disclosures
For informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice. Certain information is deemed to be reliable, but its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. Third party information may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice. Neither the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) nor any other federal or state agency has approved, determined the accuracy, or confirmed the adequacy of this article.
The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Alpha Architect, its affiliates or its employees. Our full disclosures are available here. Definitions of common statistics used in our analysis are available here (towards the bottom).
Join thousands of other readers and subscribe to our blog.